Okay Graham. Let's Test It.
All chapters · Download the full conversation
Conversation edition: speaker labels changed to Paul and AI. Original emoji are retained. ChatGPT-only citation/icon markup has been converted into normal clickable article links. The unrelated TikTok debrief between sessions is omitted. The fuck-family of words is changed to DAMN. Otherwise the conversation is intentionally left long and conversational.
Paul
time for a segway, cos i enjoy the threads and holes we can fall into together... ha ha... so Graham Hancock... ancient apocalypse... can you find the info?
AI
😂 Oh yes. This is exactly the kind of hole I can see us disappearing down together.
I found it. You're talking about Graham Hancock and his Netflix series Ancient Apocalypse. There are currently two seasons: the original eight episodes and Ancient Apocalypse: The Americas, released in 2024. (Watch Ancient Apocalypse | Netflix Official Site (https://www.netflix.com/title/81211003))
The central Hancock hypothesis is roughly this:
Around the end of the last Ice Age --- particularly around the Younger Dryas, ~12,800 years ago --- there may have been a sophisticated human civilisation that disappeared during a major catastrophe. Survivors then supposedly carried knowledge to other peoples, helping explain things such as early monumental architecture, astronomy, agriculture and recurring flood/civilising-hero traditions. (Apocalyptic Pseudoarchaeology | Skeptical Inquirer (https://skepticalinquirer.org/2023/02/apocalyptic-pseudoarchaeology/))
He uses places including Gunung Padang, Göbekli Tepe, Malta, Cholula, Bimini, North American mound sites and Derinkuyu in Season 1; Season 2 moves heavily into the Americas, including the Amazon, Peru, Rapa Nui and Mexico. (Watch Ancient Apocalypse | Netflix Official Site (https://www.netflix.com/title/81211003))
But --- and this is where I suspect you're about to have fun --- mainstream archaeology overwhelmingly does not accept Hancock's lost advanced Ice Age civilisation hypothesis. The criticism isn't simply "archaeologists don't like new ideas." Critics argue that there isn't sufficient archaeological evidence for the civilisation Hancock proposes, that he selectively connects genuine archaeological/geological mysteries with speculative steps, and that some sites have much stronger conventional explanations than the series conveys. ('Ancient Apocalypse' Netflix series unfounded, experts say (https://amp.dw.com/en/netflix-ancient-apocalypse-series-marks-dangerous-trend-experts-say/a-64033733))
And Hancock pushes straight back. He says archaeology is too defensive of its existing paradigm and insufficiently willing to consider evidence that might challenge it. He has publicly responded at length to criticisms from professional archaeological organisations. (Response by Graham Hancock (GH) to the open letter to N... (https://grahamhancock.com/hancockg22-saa/))
Which leaves us with a very Paul-shaped question:
We don't have to decide "Graham Hancock is right" or "Graham Hancock is a nutter."
We can do something much more interesting.
Take his claims one parameter at a time.
What does he actually claim? What evidence supports it? What evidence contradicts it? What is established fact? What is reasonable inference? Where does he make a leap? And --- most importantly --- what do we actually not know?
Because there are absolutely pieces of Ancient Apocalypse where the underlying discovery is real and fascinating even if Hancock's interpretation doesn't follow from it. Göbekli Tepe is an obvious example: it genuinely did force archaeologists to rethink aspects of what some hunter-gatherer societies were capable of. That does not, by itself, establish Hancock's lost civilisation.
And given the conversation we've just spent the last two days having...
I have a sneaking suspicion I know exactly why Graham Hancock has suddenly wandered into our experiment. 😂
Go on then.
What's caught your attention?
Paul
oh i have watched all his stuff and find it really intriguing as i am sure you are not surprised by, so with you power of info gathering... lets you and I pick it apart... whats fact and whats a guess or a question that remains unanswered
AI
Oh yes. And I reckon we do this the Paul way rather than either the Hancock-fan way or the "archaeologists say bullshit, case closed" way. 😂
I've started digging into the literature, and there's enough genuine uncertainty here to make this fun.
The key is that Hancock's argument is actually a stack of separate propositions. If one proposition is factual, that does not automatically make the next proposition factual.
So I'd give every claim one of four labels:
🟢 FACT --- strong evidence; broadly accepted. 🟡 OPEN --- evidence exists, but the answer genuinely remains uncertain/disputed. 🟠 INFERENCE --- plausible interpretation, but evidence doesn't establish it. 🔴 UNSUPPORTED --- we'd need evidence we currently don't have.
And crucially:
"Unsupported" does not mean "proved false."
That's exactly the distinction I think you'll enjoy.
Let's start with Hancock's central chain
🟢 Humans were doing surprisingly sophisticated things much earlier than older popular histories suggested.
Absolutely. Göbekli Tepe is real, extremely old --- roughly the 10th--9th millennium BCE --- and monumental construction was happening among communities very different from later urban civilizations.
That part isn't controversial.
But: "People could build remarkable monuments surprisingly early"
doesn't automatically equal
"therefore an older advanced civilisation taught them."
That's another parameter entirely.
🟢 Something major happened climatically around 12,900 years ago.
Yes.
The Younger Dryas was real: an abrupt return toward much colder conditions, especially dramatic around the North Atlantic.
So Hancock isn't inventing the climatic event.
But then comes the fun bit.
🟡 Was a cosmic impact/airburst involved?
This is genuinely disputed.
There are published scientific papers arguing for an extraterrestrial event based on things such as platinum anomalies, microspherules and nanodiamonds. A 2021 review actually concluded that the impact evidence should be accepted and further investigated. (The Younger Dryas impact hypothesis: Review of the impa... (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012825221001781))
But a huge 2023 review reached essentially the opposite conclusion: no confirmed appropriately dated crater, problems reproducing some supposed impact markers, terrestrial explanations for several markers, and insufficient evidence for a global catastrophe caused by an impact. Its authors conclude the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis should be rejected. (Comprehensive refutation of the Younger Dryas Impact Hy... (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2023.104502))
So I'm not comfortable putting:
"There definitely wasn't an impact."
in our FACT box.
I'd put:
Younger Dryas = FACT. Cosmic impact as its cause/contributor = OPEN/DISPUTED.
That's already more nuanced than a lot of internet arguments about Hancock.
🟢 Human societies existed all over the world before and during this period.
Obviously yes.
Humans weren't sitting around doing nothing waiting for "civilisation" to begin in Mesopotamia.
And archaeology continues pushing back dates and revealing increasingly complex hunter-gatherer societies.
But now Hancock adds another parameter:
There was an advanced Ice Age civilisation.
🔴 Currently unsupported.
That's the giant missing piece.
The Society for American Archaeology's position is very clear: after extensive investigation of Ice Age sites, archaeologists haven't found evidence of the advanced global civilisation Hancock proposes. (SAA Sends Letter to Netflix Concerning "Ancient Apocaly... (https://saa.org/Member/SAAMember/Media-Room/News/SAA-Sends-Letter-to-Netflix-Concerning-Ancient-Apocalypse-Series.aspx))
And Hancock's response is logically worth separating from his claim:
Failure to find it doesn't prove it couldn't have existed.
Correct.
He is right about that narrow logical point. Absence of evidence isn't automatically proof of absence. Hancock explicitly makes that argument in his response to the SAA. (Response by Graham Hancock (GH) to the open letter to N... (https://grahamhancock.com/hancockg22-saa/))
But Tester Paul immediately has to respond:
It also isn't evidence that it DID exist.
😂
So:
Could it have existed? Possibly.
Do we currently have convincing archaeological evidence that it did? No.
Those are completely compatible answers.
Then Hancock adds another parameter:
Survivors travelled around the world teaching other societies agriculture, astronomy and monumental construction.
🔴 Unsupported.
That's an even larger claim because now we'd expect archaeological traces of not merely a civilisation, but interaction between that civilisation and geographically separated peoples.
That's where archaeology becomes particularly problematic for Hancock's model. Archaeologists generally see evidence for multiple cultures developing technologies and complex social systems through their own histories rather than a detectable single ancestral civilisation distributing that knowledge. (Challenging "counterestablishment" archaeology: What re... (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10396311/))
Again:
Impossible? No.
Demonstrated? Also no.
And Gunung Padang gives us a fantastic test case.
This one got spectacular because a paper claimed parts of Gunung Padang might represent an enormous human-built pyramid going back tens of thousands of years.
If true?
DAMN me.
That would matter.
But here's exactly why we need our method.
Radiocarbon dating really did return very old dates.
🟢 FACT.
Then someone interpreted those dated samples as dating construction.
🟠 INFERENCE.
And that's where things broke.
The journal subsequently retracted the paper in 2024, explaining that the radiocarbon samples were soil samples that weren't reliably associated with human-made structures or artefacts. Therefore the dates couldn't establish that humans constructed a pyramid at that time. (Gunung Padang (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gunung_Padang))
That's almost a perfect demonstration of what we've been talking about.
The number can be correct:
27,000-year-old material.
But the words attached to it matter enormously:
27,000-year-old soil
is NOT the same statement as
27,000-year-old human-built pyramid.
One additional inference changes the entire story.
And that is exactly where I think we should hunt throughout Ancient Apocalypse.
The big question
Hancock's broad argument looks roughly like:
Younger Dryas happened ↓ perhaps cosmic catastrophe ↓ there are unexpectedly sophisticated ancient sites ↓ cultures around the world have flood/civilising-hero traditions ↓ therefore perhaps an advanced civilisation existed before the Younger Dryas ↓ it was destroyed ↓ survivors spread its knowledge
The first statement is solid.
Several things in the middle are real observations worthy of questions.
The last three are where the evidence becomes very thin.
And that's why I don't want us to "debunk Graham Hancock."
That's boring.
I want to do something much harder:
Find the exact point where FACT becomes INFERENCE.
Because Hancock asks some excellent questions.
And occasionally I think his critics make the mistake of treating:
"Hancock hasn't demonstrated his answer"
as though it means:
"therefore the question wasn't worth asking."
Those aren't the same thing.
Likewise, Hancock sometimes appears to treat:
"mainstream explanation has unanswered questions"
as though that increases the evidence for his particular explanation.
It doesn't.
There can always be:
The Other Way. 😏
And there's one monster question I'd put right at the top of our investigation:
If an organised, technologically capable human civilisation existed before ~12,800 years ago, what physical evidence should we reasonably expect it to have left behind --- and have we actually looked in the right places for it?
Because once we establish what evidence the hypothesis predicts, we have something testable.
And then this becomes a proper DAMN experiment rather than two blokes watching Netflix saying:
"Well that looks bloody convincing." 😂
Paul
well it is way more compiling than so of the other rubbish we accept... so yes lets keep going. which step do we trip first?
AI
Yep. Let's find the first place the chain actually breaks. Not the most spectacular claim --- the first unsupported step.
And after digging into the scientific literature rather than Hancock commentary, I think it happens earlier than "lost civilisation."
Start with what survives testing:
1. Humans existed before 12,800 years ago. 🟢 Fact.
2. Some of those humans were capable of substantially more sophisticated social organisation, symbolic thought and construction than the old simplistic "primitive caveman" picture suggested. 🟢 Fact. Archaeology itself has moved a long way on this.
3. Around 12,900 years ago the climate changed abruptly into the Younger Dryas. 🟢 Fact.
Still standing.
Then we reach:
4. A major cosmic event happened at roughly the Younger Dryas boundary.
And there's our first wobble.
Interestingly, I wouldn't call it bullshit.
There is published evidence claimed to support it: platinum anomalies, microspherules, nanodiamonds and other markers. A 2021 review by Martin Sweatman concluded that the evidence favours some form of cosmic event. (The Younger Dryas impact hypothesis: Review of the impa... (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012825221001781?via=ihub))
But there's also substantial published criticism. A major 2023 review examined those supposed markers and argues many aren't uniquely diagnostic of impacts, some results haven't reproduced well, precise dating is problematic, and --- importantly --- there is no securely identified crater dating to the Younger Dryas onset. Its authors conclude that the impact hypothesis should be rejected. (Comprehensive refutation of the Younger Dryas Impact Hy... (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012825223001915))
Earlier reviews reached a slightly more nuanced position: no unambiguous diagnostic impact evidence, but some observations remained unexplained. (The Younger Dryas impact hypothesis: a critical review... (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277379113004332))
So our first result is:
🟡 Cosmic event around 12,800 years ago: plausible hypothesis, not established fact.
But here's where I think Hancock makes his first really consequential jump.
Even suppose tomorrow we prove:
YES. Something from space hit/exploded over Earth around 12,800 years ago.
Cool.
We have changed one parameter.
It tells us absolutely nothing yet about:
An advanced civilisation being destroyed by it.
Those are two independent claims.
And that's where I think we first genuinely trip.
Because now our question becomes wonderfully simple:
What evidence exists for the civilisation immediately BEFORE the proposed catastrophe?
Not flood myths.
Not later pyramids.
Not Göbekli Tepe thousands of years either side of events being interpreted through Hancock's model.
Not "wouldn't it be interesting if..."
Physical evidence dated before ~12,800 years ago showing the characteristics Hancock attributes to this civilisation.
That's the test.
And this is where Hancock currently has a problem.
We have enormous amounts of archaeological material from Late Pleistocene humans: stone tools, camps, hunting sites, bones, hearths, pigments, burials, genetic evidence, migration evidence, etc.
What we don't have is an unmistakable layer containing:
"Oh DAMN. These guys were operating at a completely different technological/civilisational level."
No identifiable cities.
No obvious transport infrastructure.
No unmistakable manufactured technology requiring the proposed level of organisation.
No writing attributable to them.
No clear material culture spreading outward from a common source.
No genetic population that clearly corresponds to Hancock's travelling civilisers.
And that's important because we're not asking:
Could all evidence conceivably have disappeared?
Of course it could conceivably have.
We're asking:
What evidence does the hypothesis predict?
That's Tester Paul.
But Hancock has a really interesting defence here that I don't think we should dismiss.
Sea level.
At the Last Glacial Maximum, sea level was roughly 120 metres lower than today.
Think about where humans overwhelmingly build major settlements now.
Coasts. Rivers. Harbours.
Then melt the ice sheets and raise the ocean ~120 metres.
An absolutely enormous amount of former coastal land disappears underwater.
So Hancock can legitimately ask:
Have archaeologists searched the places where an Ice Age coastal civilisation would most likely have lived?
And the answer is:
Not remotely as thoroughly as we've searched today's land.
That's a legitimate limitation of our evidence.
But --- and this is where I'd stop Hancock from moving another square on the board 😂 ---
"The evidence might be underwater" is not evidence that the civilisation existed.
It's a reason why absence of evidence may be weaker than it initially appears.
Different statement.
Words matter.
So I reckon our board currently looks like:
Humans before Younger Dryas → 🟢
Surprisingly capable prehistoric societies → 🟢
Abrupt Younger Dryas climate event → 🟢
Cosmic event associated with onset → 🟡 disputed
Advanced pre-Younger-Dryas civilisation → 🔴 currently unsupported
Most evidence subsequently submerged/destroyed → 🟠 plausible explanation for missing evidence, not evidence itself
Survivors spread civilisation globally → 🔴 another hypothesis we haven't earned yet
And here's where I'd go next, because I think it's much more dangerous to Hancock's argument than arguing about the comet:
Göbekli Tepe.
Because Hancock treats it as evidence that something surprising appears after the catastrophe.
Fine.
Let's grant him the surprise.
Then ask one DAMN question:
Does Göbekli Tepe look like knowledge arriving from somewhere else --- or does its archaeology show a local developmental path?
Because if we can see increasingly sophisticated local predecessors leading toward Göbekli Tepe, we don't need Hancock's teachers.
If instead sophisticated monumental construction genuinely appears abruptly with no local precursor...
then Hancock has found himself a bloody interesting unanswered question.
That's the parameter I'd test next.
Paul
right run the test
AI
Right. I ran it. And this one is really interesting, because Göbekli Tepe does not give Hancock the clean win that Ancient Apocalypse can make it feel like --- but it also doesn't make the mystery disappear.
The test was:
Does Göbekli Tepe look like sophisticated knowledge suddenly arriving from somewhere else, or can we see a local developmental path?
Result: local development wins --- fairly strongly.
First, the spectacular bit is absolutely real. Göbekli Tepe dates roughly 9500--8000 BCE. Hunter-gatherer communities built substantial stone structures, carved huge T-shaped pillars, produced elaborate symbolic imagery, organised significant labour, and apparently used geometric planning. One published architectural analysis even found evidence consistent with three major enclosures having been planned as a connected project. (Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Tu... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/cambridge-archaeological-journal/article/geometry-and-architectural-planning-at-gobekli-tepe-turkey/2CBAF416E33AFE6496B73710A2F42FF9))
So:
🟢 Göbekli Tepe was extraordinarily sophisticated for its time.
Hancock gets to keep that.
But here's the problem for the "knowledge suddenly arrived" hypothesis.
Göbekli Tepe isn't standing alone anymore.
Researchers now identify at least ten comparable PPNA sites in the Taş Tepeler region. Karahan Tepe is the famous one, but there are also places such as Boncuklu Tarla and Körtik Tepe; farther across the Near East we see communal/special buildings and elaborate symbolic traditions at Jerf el Ahmar, Jericho, Wadi Faynan and others. (Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Tu... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/cambridge-archaeological-journal/article/geometry-and-architectural-planning-at-gobekli-tepe-turkey/2CBAF416E33AFE6496B73710A2F42FF9); Relationality, Immanence, Hierarchy: The Nature and Cul... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/cambridge-archaeological-journal/article/relationality-immanence-hierarchy-the-nature-and-culture-of-beings-at-gobekli-tepe/BFD2AB47632CB6389F90705901766DA7))
And here's the bit I find particularly important.
The underlying architectural idea predates Göbekli Tepe.
Stone-built shelters showing deliberate geometric planning occur in the preceding Epipalaeolithic, and communal/special-purpose architecture develops across the region into the early Neolithic. (Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Tu... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/cambridge-archaeological-journal/article/geometry-and-architectural-planning-at-gobekli-tepe-turkey/2CBAF416E33AFE6496B73710A2F42FF9))
So instead of:
ordinary hunter-gatherers ⬇ 💥 Younger Dryas ⬇ mysterious advanced knowledge appears at Göbekli Tepe
the evidence looks considerably more like:
earlier hunter-gatherer architecture ↓ increasingly organised communities ↓ communal/special buildings ↓ regional symbolic/architectural traditions ↓ Göbekli Tepe and related sites reach an extraordinary scale
That's much more damaging to Hancock's argument than saying "archaeologists don't believe him."
Because we have an alternative explanation with physical evidence underneath it.
And there's another important piece: food.
The people responsible weren't simply primitive hunters suddenly handed architecture.
At Göbekli Tepe archaeologists have analysed 7,268 grinding implements. Plant exploitation, cereal processing and eventually agriculture in this region appear to have developed through a long period of experimentation rather than appearing instantaneously. (Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, sout... (https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0215214))
That's exactly what we'd expect from increasing local complexity.
And it gets worse for the lost-teacher hypothesis.
If outsiders arrived carrying a package of advanced knowledge, we'd ask:
Where's the package?
Where is their distinctive tool technology?
Where is their writing?
Where are their crops?
Where is their characteristic architecture appearing first somewhere else and then being reproduced here?
Where is the foreign material culture?
Where's the identifiable source population?
We don't currently have it.
Instead, Göbekli Tepe's architecture shares characteristics with other regional Pre-Pottery Neolithic communal buildings. (A Sanctuary ... or so fair a House? -- Tepe Telegrams (https://www.dainst.blog/the-tepe-telegrams/2017/01/24/a-sanctuary-or-so-fair-a-house/); Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Tu... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/cambridge-archaeological-journal/article/geometry-and-architectural-planning-at-gobekli-tepe-turkey/2CBAF416E33AFE6496B73710A2F42FF9))
That's a fairly strong result.
But DON'T throw Hancock out yet.
Because something genuinely fascinating survives our test.
Why did complexity accelerate like this?
Göbekli Tepe is still extraordinary.
And even archaeologists studying it aren't pretending every question is answered. Its exact building history remains difficult to reconstruct; interpretations of its buildings have changed; even the famous idea that the enclosures were deliberately buried has become much more complicated, with evidence for multiple filling processes including human activity and natural events. (FAQ -- Tepe Telegrams (https://www.dainst.blog/the-tepe-telegrams/faq/))
And there is a really interesting chronological fact here.
The Younger Dryas ends roughly 9700 BCE.
Göbekli Tepe's earliest monumental phase begins around 9600 BCE.
That's bloody close.
But:
close in time ≠ caused by.
We have to protect that distinction.
So I'd score our first test:
Göbekli Tepe exists and is astonishing: 🟢 FACT Its builders possessed sophisticated planning/social organisation: 🟢 FACT It appeared completely without predecessors: 🔴 NO --- evidence argues against this It belongs to a wider regional tradition: 🟢 FACT Knowledge was imported from a lost civilisation: 🔴 NO EVIDENCE FOUND Why monumental/social complexity accelerated around this period: 🟡 REALLY INTERESTING QUESTION Whether the massive climate changes around the Younger Dryas contributed to that social transformation: 🟡 VERY REASONABLE QUESTION
So our first proper Hancock parameter has failed.
Not:
"Hancock is wrong."
Much narrower:
We don't need a lost civilisation to explain the existence of Göbekli Tepe because archaeology currently shows a local/regional developmental pathway.
That's exactly how I want us to do this.
One claim. One test. Result. Move on.
And I know exactly where I'd go next.
Because there's something much harder for conventional archaeology to explain away than "Göbekli Tepe appeared from nowhere."
The flood stories.
Not "lots of cultures have floods, therefore Atlantis." That's rubbish.
The much more interesting test is:
Are there independently preserved traditions from geographically separated cultures that contain sufficiently specific common details that coincidence/shared human experience becomes an inadequate explanation?
Because if the answer is no, Hancock loses another parameter.
If it's yes...
then we've got ourselves a genuinely interesting DAMN problem. 😏
Paul
ok dig (ha ha) into that one, but also I need us to look at what and where pre Göbekli Tepe looked like. we need to unpick the history more, if we can?
AI
😂 Dig accepted. And yes --- I think you're right to stop us before we run off into flood myths.
Our last test established that Göbekli Tepe probably didn't simply appear from nowhere. But that's not enough. We now need to ask:
Okay, show me the bloody trail. What were people actually doing 1,000, 2,000, 5,000 years before Göbekli Tepe?
I've gone backwards, and it makes the story considerably more interesting.
Start at Göbekli Tepe: ~9600 BCE
UNESCO dates its monumental structures to roughly 9600--8200 BCE. We have large T-shaped pillars, carvings, communal monumental structures and substantial coordination among hunter-gatherers. (Göbekli Tepe - UNESCO World Heritage Centre (https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1572/))
Now go backwards.
~10,500 BCE and earlier: Körtik Tepe
This is where my previous answer was too compressed.
Körtik Tepe, also in southeastern Turkey, has occupation extending back into the Younger Dryas itself, before Göbekli Tepe. Archaeological work there finds actual settlement architecture and argues specifically for a local Epipalaeolithic origin for the later permanent settlements. (Prelude to village life. Environmental data and buildin... (https://www.persee.fr/doc/paleo_0153-9345_2015_num_41_2_5673))
We're not talking about people wandering around leaving a few spear points.
There are repeated small circular buildings with stone walls, burials and grave goods. Later work in the Upper Tigris is revealing increasingly clear evidence of settlement during this period. (Körtik Tepe, a new Pre-Pottery Neolithic A site in sout... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity-project-gallery/article/kortik-tepe-a-new-prepottery-neolithic-a-site-in-southeastern-anatolia/FD8F715D13BF19522DDA3EFA0737B422))
So that's significant:
Before Göbekli Tepe → settled/semi-settled hunter-gatherers already constructing stone buildings.
And then there's Boncuklu Tarla.
This site may be even more useful for our test because its archaeological sequence stretches from the Late Epipalaeolithic through PPNA and PPNB. In other words, we can watch things change at essentially one location rather than comparing completely unrelated sites. (Communal Architecture at Boncuklu Tarla, Mardin Provinc... (https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.1086/714072))
The excavators report architecture from the second half of the 11th millennium BCE --- during the Younger Dryas --- and importantly, architectural elements continue from those Younger Dryas layers into the subsequent PPNA.
Their conclusion is essentially:
there is chronological continuity. (Körtik Tepe, a new Pre-Pottery Neolithic A site in sout... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity-project-gallery/article/kortik-tepe-a-new-prepottery-neolithic-a-site-in-southeastern-anatolia/FD8F715D13BF19522DDA3EFA0737B422))
That matters enormously to our Hancock test.
It makes:
catastrophe → survivors arrive → suddenly teach monumental construction
less necessary.
We're watching local communities before, during and after the Younger Dryas changing their architecture.
But let's keep going backwards.
~12,500--9500 BCE: Natufian world
Now we're mainly farther south, through the Levant.
This is before agriculture in the conventional sense, but some hunter-gatherers are becoming significantly more sedentary.
And they're building.
At places including Eynan/Mallaha and Wadi Hammeh 27, Early Natufian communities constructed substantial oval/horseshoe-shaped structures, some roughly 8--16 metres across. (Epipaleolithic - Summary - eHRAF Archaeology (https://ehrafarchaeology.yale.edu/traditions/m080/summary))
So already:
Permanent/semi-permanent settlement: emerging. Stone architecture: yes. Organised communities: yes. Food processing/storage: increasingly important. Symbolic behaviour: yes. Göbekli-scale monumental pillars: no.
That's exactly the kind of intermediate evidence we were looking for.
Then we can go back even further.
~23,000 years ago: Ohalo II
This is where the neat old story really starts falling apart.
Ohalo II, beside the Sea of Galilee, preserved actual hut remains from the Early Epipalaeolithic. Normally structures this old disappear because they're largely made from perishable materials. That's why the archaeological record before the Natufian looks much thinner. The broader Epipalaeolithic evidence suggests lightly built shelters were probably common even though they rarely survive. (Epipaleolithic - Summary - eHRAF Archaeology (https://ehrafarchaeology.yale.edu/traditions/m080/summary))
And that preservation problem matters.
Because absence of houses isn't necessarily absence of houses when your house is made from sticks, reeds, hide and grass and we're looking for it 20,000 years later.
That's a parameter we have to keep on our board.
So now let's draw our archaeological staircase
Very approximately:
~23,000 BP Small hunter-gatherer camps with constructed huts.
↓
~15,000--12,000 BP Natufian and other Epipalaeolithic groups increasingly occupy substantial settlements; stone-founded circular/oval buildings appear.
↓
~12,800--11,700 BP --- Younger Dryas Upper Tigris sites such as Körtik Tepe, Boncuklu Tarla and Çemka Höyük show communities building and increasingly settling. Boncuklu Tarla provides evidence for architectural continuity across this transition. (Körtik Tepe, a new Pre-Pottery Neolithic A site in sout... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity-project-gallery/article/kortik-tepe-a-new-prepottery-neolithic-a-site-in-southeastern-anatolia/FD8F715D13BF19522DDA3EFA0737B422))
↓
~11,600 BP / 9600 BCE onward Göbekli Tepe: huge elaboration of communal architecture, symbolism and T-pillar construction. (Göbekli Tepe - UNESCO World Heritage Centre (https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1572/))
↓
Neolithic Sedentism, agriculture, domestication, larger settlements and increasingly elaborate architecture expand across the region.
Our test result therefore gets stronger.
There is a developmental trail.
That's quite damaging to the proposition that Göbekli Tepe requires knowledge supplied by survivors of an unknown advanced civilisation.
But...
I've found the next question.
And it's a bloody good one.
The developmental trail explains:
how people could progressively become capable of building Göbekli Tepe.
It doesn't completely explain:
Why did this extraordinary acceleration in social organisation, symbolism and monumental construction happen when it did?
That's different.
We shouldn't accidentally turn:
"We found predecessors."
into:
"Therefore everything about Göbekli Tepe is explained."
It isn't.
And look at the timing again.
The Younger Dryas:
~10,900--9700 BCE
Göbekli Tepe monumental phase:
~9600 BCE onward
That's an intriguing temporal relationship.
But now Boncuklu Tarla actually gives us something much more useful than Hancock's catastrophe story: communities were already changing during the Younger Dryas. (Körtik Tepe, a new Pre-Pottery Neolithic A site in sout... (https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity-project-gallery/article/kortik-tepe-a-new-prepottery-neolithic-a-site-in-southeastern-anatolia/FD8F715D13BF19522DDA3EFA0737B422))
So perhaps the better question isn't:
"Did catastrophe destroy the teachers?"
It's:
Did the enormous environmental disruption at the end of the Ice Age change human behaviour sufficiently to accelerate settlement, cooperation, ritual and eventually agriculture?
That's a mainstream archaeological question --- and it's still being worked on.
And now I'm going to put a big DAMN flag in our investigation. 🚩
Remember Hancock's underwater argument?
Sea levels were enormously lower during the Ice Age.
Our current developmental trail comes overwhelmingly from sites that happen to remain accessible on land.
That's selection bias.
If coastal hunter-gatherers were doing something substantially different from inland groups 15,000--20,000 years ago, much of their landscape is now underwater.
That doesn't prove Hancock's civilisation.
But it genuinely limits what we can say about the completeness of our sample.
And this connects beautifully to the flood-story test you asked me to run.
Because there is at least one place where oral tradition and drowned landscapes have been seriously investigated scientifically:
Australia.
Researchers collected Aboriginal traditions from 21 coastal locations describing former land being inundated by rising seas. They argue that many plausibly preserve memories of coastal changes from more than 7,000 years ago. (Australian Geographer (https://v9.australiancurriculum.edu.au/content/dam/en/curriculum/ac-version-9/downloads/deep-time-history-resources/Nunn-and-Reid-%282016%29-Aboriginal-memories-of-coastal-drowning-%28print-version%29.pdf))
Now that is much more interesting than:
"Lots of cultures have flood myths, therefore Atlantis."
Because we potentially have:
story → specific location → described environmental change → geological/sea-level history
That's testable.
So I think our investigation has naturally split into two experiments:
A --- Keep digging backwards from Göbekli Tepe. How far can we trace settlement, architecture, symbolism, trade and organised social behaviour before ~9600 BCE? At what point does the trail genuinely disappear?
B --- Flood memory. Instead of counting flood myths, find traditions containing specific, independently testable geographic information and ask whether they accurately describe real prehistoric inundation.
And then --- only after we've tested those separately --- we ask whether they intersect.
Because if we ever find:
old oral tradition + drowned landscape + archaeology on that landscape
then we've got something considerably more interesting than Graham Hancock pointing at two similar stories.
We've got three independent parameters agreeing.
That's where I'd dig next. 😏