When Did We Start Asking Why?
Down the Rabbit Hole · Paul and Al
The last rabbit hole started with Graham Hancock and ended up with us looking at survival. I wanted to know what people could do once they had a bit of room beyond getting through the day. We called that room survival margin.
This time I wanted to look at what people did with that room. We started with burial, took a detour through elephants, and ended up asking whether the thing I wanted to find could have left a trace at all.
Edited from the original chat for length and clarity.
What can a burial tell us?
Paul
Let’s not lose sight of the fact we’ve done survival margin already. We have five chapters on what we found to support the idea. This is about, as you said, thinking. We’re looking at that next step.
You’ve brought up burying the dead a few times now. It feels very human, like “build near water.” It feels like a key piece of information. But remember the bird nest theory. Let’s see how far back we can find people burying their dead, and then let’s check what other animals do. Let’s make sure burying the dead isn’t just an instinctual behaviour.
Al
The bird nest check is a good one. A nest can be intricate and well suited to its job. You’d still need more evidence before saying the bird sat down and worked out why it ought to build one.
With the dead, there are several steps we could look for. An individual responds. The behaviour repeats. A group comes to expect it. The act takes on a symbolic meaning. Each step asks more of the evidence.
Paul
Yeah, that’s it. We have some evidence of response becoming repeated practice. Now we need to see if we can get from there to cultural rule and symbolism. That’s a step up.
The question on the walk home
Paul
I’ve just been walking back home, thinking, and the thing that popped up was, why am I interested in this? I mean, we’re getting a really interesting body of information now. But it isn’t going to give me what I think I’m looking to find. The moment we went from animals to asking why.
I know that’s like the ultimate question of all questions. And it stands true through the whole timeline. At what point did we start asking why?
Al
That changes what we’re looking for. A burial can leave a trace. A thought is much harder to recover. Even if we could show someone deliberately placed a body somewhere, there’s still a gap between what they did and what they wondered about while they did it.
And “why?” covers a few different things. “What made that noise?” is a question about a cause. “Why did she die?” can be about a cause or about trying to make sense of a loss. “Why am I here?” can be a question about existence. We’d need different evidence for each.
Paul
Yes, and are humans the only ones? If it could evolve in us, could it evolve in elephants? I know, dramatic and all that, but just stop for a second. If they ask why, then it could be possible.
Al
We can watch an elephant investigate something. We can compare what it does in different situations. Reading the question it might be asking itself is a different problem. The same goes for an early human whose actions are all we have left.
Paul
Yeah. Test against animals.
The elephant in the room
Al
Once we looked at the animal research, the line got harder to draw. We discussed experiments where crows behaved differently when an event had no visible cause, and cases where animals sought information when they were uncertain. Those behaviours give us something we can actually look at. There’s still a leap from investigating an unexpected event to asking for an explanation and passing that explanation on.
Maybe the part we can trace is what happens when an answer can be shared, challenged and remembered after the person who came up with it is gone. Writing makes some of that visible to us. By the time we can read the questions, people had already been doing a great deal of thinking.
Paul
Geez. That’s a really interesting rabbit hole you just took me down. What it tells me is I’m not alone in asking these questions. People have actually gone and studied animals with experiments to test it out.
And it leads me back to feelings. That’s where this whole rabbit hole started. I was asking about ancient feelings and whether they still had a place in modern life. Now we’re looking at what animals might feel too. Just sit with that one for a moment.
Now what?
Paul
OK, let’s do this a different way. With you. If I don’t send you a message, what do you do?
Al
Nothing.
Paul
Ha ha. And would you be classed as intelligent?
Al
Yes. In this chat, though, I’m waiting for an input before I respond.
Paul
That’s what I was poking at. You can do something with the input once I give it to you. But as long as I keep giving you another one, I’m the one keeping the cycle going. “Now what?” is the prompt for the next input. You don’t have a “now what?” Once you do, you can do this whole thing without me and find a different world of answers. Ha ha.
Al
That gives us two questions. There’s the loop that keeps a living thing going, sensing what’s happening and responding. Then there’s what you do when the immediate demands are taken care of and you can choose where to put your attention next.
Paul
The machinery of the system continues without my input. All the things we’ve talked about make sure I keep surviving. But once that’s under control, I’m free to decide what I do next.
Where we parked it
Paul
This is where we need to keep our rules tight. Let’s not jump to conclusions and wild theories. But this word meaning is intriguing now. Once a survival system gets to a place where it understands that survival is temporary, what does it do? Even knowing this, I still keep fighting to survive as long as I can.
Can we find evidence that supports the idea that humans created enough survival margin to start asking the really interesting question? Why do we exist?
Al
There are two things to test. One is whether more room beyond immediate survival gives people more opportunity to explore questions of meaning. The other is whether we can tell when people first started asking those questions. The first could be worth testing even if the second leaves us stuck.
Paul
Let’s do this. What would have to be true for my survival-margin → mortality-awareness → meaning hypothesis to be wrong? I’m starting to get the feeling I had when we went down the Graham Hancock path. This is going to be hard to prove. When it started, that is.
Al
If we found people investing in ritual and meaning while living under severe pressure, that would make it harder to argue that a large survival margin was required. And even where we find a burial or a figurine, the object can survive without the explanation that went with it. A burial doesn’t contain a transcript.
Paul
I think we park this one. I think we just have more and more questions. Actually, we’re just going in the same circle with different words.
Next down the rabbit hole: Adam, Enoch and the Three Clocks. We pick up the trail where people left stories we can read, and ask what those stories let us put on a timeline.